Australian 4WD Hire in court for alleged breaches of consumer law

18 April 2019

The ACCC has instituted proceedings against four-wheel drive vehicle rental company Smart Corporation Pty Ltd (trading as Australian 4WD Hire), alleging it used unfair contract terms, engaged in unconscionable conduct, and made false or misleading representations in relation to insurance cover, in breach of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL).

The ACCC alleges that, since 2016, Australian 4WD Hire’s standard form contracts have included unfair terms that allowed it to charge customers for a range of driving behaviours which it claimed would cause excessive wear and tear or damage to its vehicles.

These driving behaviours included driving at night outside built-up areas, above the speed limit, or when visibility was poor.  Australian 4WD Hire relied on GPS data to determine whether customers had engaged in these driving behaviours.

“We consider these contract terms are unfair because they allow Australian 4WD Hire to charge customers for purported vehicle damage without having to prove any actual damage occurred,” ACCC Chair Rod Sims said.

“We are seeking to have these terms declared unfair by the Court so Australian 4WD Hire can’t enforce them against its customers.”

The ACCC also alleges that Australian 4WD Hire acted unconscionably by enforcing these terms against certain consumers and withholding at least $500 of their security deposits for excessive vehicle wear and tear. When these customers disputed these actions, the company threatened them with further charges and referral to authorities unless they  acquiesced.

“Australian 4WD Hire’s alleged treatment of some of its customers was of particular concern to the ACCC and is the basis of our unconscionable conduct claim against the company,” Mr Sims said.

It is also alleged that, since 2014, Australian 4WD Hire has represented on its website that all rental vehicles would have the benefit of off-road insurance when in fact more than half of its vehicles were only insured for damage to third-party property. Australian 4WD Hire’s contract also gave it the discretion to not lodge an insurance claim for single vehicle incidents and instead hold customers liable for all costs.

“We allege Australian 4WD Hire gave its customers a false sense of security by representing they would have the benefit of being covered by insurance, in particular for the off-road use of the vehicles, when this was not necessarily the case” Mr Sims said.

The ACCC alleges that Australian 4WD Hire’s Fleet Manager, Mr Vitali Roesch, and director, Ms Maryna Kosukhina were knowingly concerned in the alleged breaches of the Australian Consumer Law.

The ACCC is seeking declarations, pecuniary penalties, compensation for customers, and banning orders against Mr Roesch and Ms Kosukhina.

Background:

Australian 4WD Hire is a four-wheel drive vehicle rental company which operates in locations across Australia including Alice Springs, Broome, Cairns, Darwin and the Gold Coast.

The attached document below contains the ACCC’s initiating court documents in relation to this matter. We will not be uploading further documents in the event these initial documents are subsequently amended.

Concise Statement

ACCC v Smart Corporation Pty Ltd_Concise Statement ( PDF 709.52 KB )

Release number: 
55/19
ACCC Infocentre: 

Use this form to make a general enquiry.

Media enquiries: 
Media team - 1300 138 917